BLOG: ‘Stop treating lettings like a grubby cousin of social housing’
Goodlord boss William Reeve accuses politicians of demonising private landlords and the homes they rent out, while turning a blind eye to social housing.

As I traversed the event spaces, panels and pubs of the Labour Party Conference last month, one thing struck me: Housing is back.
At conferences in recent years, housing policy held something of the “second cousin invited to your wedding because your mum made you” position.
Housing was there, but it wasn’t centre stage. This year, that changed. Housing was everywhere. And while this was a welcome boost for a subject that deserves to be at the top of the national policy agenda, there was a worrying undercurrent to much of the discussion – how people were speaking about the private rental sector.
During the many housing panels, roundtables and meetings I attended, the rental sector was frequently described in unfavourable terms. By contrast, the social housing sector was spoken about in almost reverential tones. This two-tier tenor made me deeply uneasy.
Discussions implied that private rents were an unfortunate consequence of a capitalist system – beset with landlords on the make and tenants at their wit’s end. While I can understand the headline-grabbing appeal of such messaging, this is a deeply dangerous path for a governing party to tread.
The rental sector is the bedrock of our current housing system. More than five million households are tenants in privately rented properties.
Complex
Despite years of complex legislative reforms and a market littered with more red tape than ever before, landlords are continuing to make these properties available.
Tenants, who are the chief beneficiaries of the recent and sweeping rental reforms, are feeling more optimistic.
Although the market is far from perfect in an era of mounting pressure, it’s faring remarkably well.
On the other side, social housing is in chaos. Demand far exceeds supply in an era where Local Authority coffers are bare and promises to “build baby build” fail to materialise into bricks and mortar.
This is compounded by far too many social housing tenants remaining in subsidised homes long after they have, on paper, out-earned the need to remain there.
Staying put
As The Economist pointed out in a recent piece, 11% of social homes go to people in the top 40% of earners. Once in, people (quite logically) are staying put.
This means we have a deeply disjoined and imbalanced market that incentivises better off people to remain in social housing, while thousands in real housing distress languish on waiting lists.
This is why talking about the PRS as if it’s a grubby cousin is so unhelpful.
This is why talking about the PRS as if it’s a grubby cousin is so unhelpful.
A truly functioning rental market would treat private rents and social rents as two sides of the same coin. We should actively pursue policies that target subsidies to those in genuine need while maintaining the same standards for all rented housing – whoever provides it.
Instead, we have a two-tier market where one set of property owners (i.e. councils) must offer discounts averaging 50% on rents, thereby killing incentives to build or invest and pushing private rents up too high.
What I would have loved to hear in the hallowed halls of Liverpool’s finest conference venues was more joined-up, informed thinking.
Radical change
We need radical change if we want to put the whole lettings market on a surer footing. It’s essential to explore concepts such as means testing eligibility for subsidised rent or even obligating councils to charge market rent on social lets, then addressing affordability through means tested housing benefits.
This would level-up the market, increase competition, drive down private rents and improve labour mobility. This is the kind of important conversation we need to be having, even if it feels uncomfortable.
At a time of such acute pressure on both sides of the market, we cannot afford for the power brokers in Westminster to see private rents as the enemy.
Housing won’t remain at the top table forever. We must therefore seize the day and lobby for better policies that benefit all. But if we keep ‘othering’ the PRS in such discussions, the opportunities to strengthen the system will pass us by.
Author bio: William Reeve is CEO of Goodlord





