Long-awaited leasehold reforms welcomed but questions remain
The Government has finally unveiled its Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill but there are still questions about how the changes will work.

Campaigners have vowed to ensure long-awaited leasehold reform progresses through Parliament.
It comes as the Government finally unveiled legislation this week that vows to bring the controversial 1,000-year-old leasehold system to an end.
The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill promises to cap ground rents at £250 per year, abolish marriage value calculations for leasehold extensions and to pave the way for commonhold.
It comes as the Government confirmed that leaseholders will get stronger rights to challenge service charges from April 2027 and there will be new rules on making service and buildings insurance charges clearer from November 2027.
The much-delayed moves have been welcomed but there are still fears of court challenges from freeholders and questions about how much leaseholders will instead be charged to extend their lease.
Katie Kendrick, founder of the National Leasehold Campaign, says: “We welcome the Government’s commitment to commonhold and its ambition to make it the default form of homeownership in the future. But success will not be measured by good intentions. It will be measured by whether existing leaseholders can actually afford to benefit from these reforms.
“If the cost of acquiring a freehold remains too high, millions of leaseholders could still find themselves locked out of commonhold and trapped in the very system they have spent years campaigning to change.
“This Bill has the potential to be truly transformative. We now need to ensure the detail matches the ambition and that nobody is left behind. For over a decade, leaseholders have fought to expose the leasehold scandal and secure justice for leaseholders. Today marks a major step forward, but our job is not finished until existing leaseholders have a realistic and affordable route out of leasehold and into commonhold.”
Linz Darlington, leasehold extension specialist and Founder of Homehold, says: “Once the combined legislation finally takes effect, leaseholders with 80 years or fewer left on their lease stand to gain from the abolition of ‘marriage value’. Those with high ground rents – above either 0.1% of property value or £250 – should find that a lease extension will be cheaper under the new rules.
“Crucially, though, the Bill will not set the underlying percentage rates that set the price of lease extensions. Those figures are being left to secondary legislation, meaning we still don’t know how much leaseholders will save, or whether people with more than 80 years remaining could even end up paying more.
“The Bill is just starting its parliamentary journey. Other housing bills have taken 12 months or more to make it through the process, suggesting it is unlikely to be implemented until 2028 at the earliest. Considering the complexity of the legislation, and the fact there are ongoing legal challenges from freeholders due to be heard in the Court of Appeal next year, it could still be a lot later than that.”
Commonhold questions
There are questions about how suitable commonhold is as an alternative to leasehold.
Simon Gerrard, Chairman of Martyn Gerrard Estate Agents, says: “Commonhold is an opportunity that has been around for 20 years, with just a handful of use cases in the country – what does that tell you about how successful it is as a framework?
“Buildings cannot be maintained on transparency alone. Service charges will become harder for the freeholder to recover, meaning works cannot be carried out, and the building will fall into disrepair. This will only be exacerbated under commonhold, as even where legal action is taken, the cost of recovering the money could exceed the amount being pursued due to proposed legislation removing the ability to recover legal costs.
“Essentially, the move leaves the responsibility of the building to the freeholder, or joint owners under commonhold, but without the ability to recover costs. Being a freeholder of a block of flats or an owner under commonhold will become a liability, eroding the value of the entire building against a backdrop of an already falling market.”
“You’ll find buildings falling into disrepair everywhere because of conflict between the community that lives in a building, with nobody wanting to spend money, and no one to adjudicate. It’s like giving a child a driving licence when they don’t know how to drive a car.”

Mark Chick, Association of Leasehold Enfranchisement Practitioners Director and Senior Partner at Bishop & Sewell LLP, says: “Commonhold gives owners more control. It also means making decisions together about repairs, reserves and who pays for what.
“People need to know what they’re taking on before they buy or vote to convert. That takes practical guidance, trained advisers and enough capacity at the Leasehold Advisory Service and HM Land Registry. Our members look forward to working with Government and Parliament to get the detail right and put these reforms into practice.
“Another important aspect which should not be overlooked is the risk that goes with managing a complex or multi-use site. Good quality managing agents will be key to this. Much has been said about commonhold of itself ‘reducing costs’, but building management and maintenance costs will be the same regardless of land tenure. However, commonhold does represent a chance for all owners to have a say in how their building is managed. Whether all flat owners will engage fully with that process remains to be seen.”

Paula Higgins, Chief Executive of the HomeOwners Alliance, says: “Making commonhold the default for most new flats is welcome and long overdue. If you buy a flat, you should own it outright and have a say in how your building is run and how your money is spent.
“We need to learn from what happened last time. The 2002 Act gave us commonhold, but fewer than 20 developments took it up. Developers had a financial reason to stick with leasehold, mortgages were harder to come by and existing blocks needed everyone’s consent to switch. Bringing that threshold down to 50% is a big step forward, but it only helps if residents can afford to buy the freehold in the first place.
“Flat owners will need to get involved and work with their neighbours on repairs, budgets and how the building is managed. Flat owners in many other countries already do this, and there’s every reason we can make it work here too.
“There’s a long road ahead. We need steady progress to get lenders and conveyancers ready and make switching affordable for existing leaseholders. Otherwise we risk a two-tier market where buyers of new flats get more control while people who already own leasehold flats could find theirs harder to sell.”





